Had to give it 5 stars
This is one great eyeliner. I gave up eyeliner for a few years because I couldn't find one that was easy to put on, easy to take off, and didn't smudge. This one does it all + it stays on all day and looks natural. I think if older ladies like myself (I'm 70) want to wear eyeliner, this would be the one to try.
Rated 5 out of 5